Here's an opinion that is likely to be unpopular, given the general backlash to B. Favre I've encountered in various circles. It's Brett Favre, for Christ's sake! If he wants to play for The Pack this season, it's beyond me why he wasn't welcomed with open arms. I understand The Pack's thinking about moving on, but does anyone really think they're going to be as good with Aaron Rodgers as they were (and could be) with B. Favre under Center? I also understand that it could be hard to take Favre seriously after the tearful press conference a few months back. But once again, we're talking about Brett-friggin-Favre! The moment he expressed an interest in playing, The Pack should've been all over it. Could you honestly start A-Rodg over a pro-bowler with the longest active starting streak in NFL history?
Mike McCarthy says Favre wasn't in the right frame of mind to play for The Pack, and Favre himself says he
couldn't put aside the issues he was having with team management. What I'd love to know is how the players feel about it all - unfortunately, we'll probably never know the truth (or at least not for a number of years). This isn't Steve Young replacing Joe Montana. This is an unproven, injury-prone Aaron Rodgers stepping in to lead The Pack. If it's true that the reports by Ted Thompson that Favre turned them down in March were an embellishment, then that (among many other things) makes this a PR nightmare for The Pack for years to come - particularly if they struggle with the start of the "A-Rodg" era.
As for Favre, many Packer fans have turned on him, calling him anything from a selfish prima donna to a "traitor." To that, I say get over yourselves! All this nonsense about Favre "owing" it to the fans not to play for anyone else is just that - nonsense. For one, he's already played for another team. He started his career with the Falcons. For another, does anyone remember Reggie White with the Panthers? Is anyone going to remember MJ with the Washington Wizards as opposed to the Bulls? I think not. Favre's place in Packer lore should be solid pretty much no matter what he does the rest of his life (absent him becoming a mass murderer or something along those lines). Odds at this point are that if B. Favre plays again, it's going to be for another team. So what? You can still cheer for the Packers (and A-Rodg) against whatever team B. Favre plays for. It doesn't mean you have to disown the man himself. And if you do, you never were much of a fan in the first place. Are people just pissed because they all blew a grand on B. Favre retirement memorabilia? Seriously. He put The Pack back on the map, and no matter what he does from here on out, cut the guy some slack. He just wants to play football.
Rant over.
UPDATE: Foxsports.com is reporting that B. Favre has been traded to the Jets.